Gender Differences
See also:
A Gender difference is a distinction of biological and/or
physiological characteristics typically associated with either males or
females of a species in general. In the study of humans,
socio-political issues arise in classifying whether a sex difference
results from the biology of gender.
This article focuses on quantitative differences which are based on a
gradient and involve different averages. For example, men are taller
than women on average, but an individual woman may be taller than an
individual man.
Other articles describe differences which clearly represent a binary male/female spilt, such as human reproduction. Some women give birth to babies; men don't.
Though some sex differences are controversial, they are not to be confused with sexist stereotypes.
Possible causes: some theories
The existence of a gender difference does not necessarily identify whether the trait is due to nature or environment.
Some traits are obviously innate (for example, reproductive organs),
others obviously environmental (for example, given names), while for
others the relationship is either multi-cause or unknown.
From the viewpoint of evolutionary psychology (championed by David Buss, Steven Pinker, Desmond Morris, Daniel Dennett,
and others) modern humans have inherited natural traits that were
adaptive in a prehistoric environment, including traits that had
different advantages for males versus females (see Sexual selection). Gender role theory and Alice Eagly
claims that boys and girls learn the appropriate behavior and attitudes
from the family and overall culture they grow up with, and so
non-physical gender differences are a product of socialization. These
are not all mutually exclusive theories: it is possible that gender
differences are partially innate but are then reinforced and
exaggerated by the environment.
Some feminists see gender differences as caused by patriarchy or discrimination, although difference feminism argues for an acceptance of gender differences. Traditional masculists tend to see gender differences as inherent in human nature, while liberal masculists may challenge traditional roles.
Traditional Abrahamic religions see gender differences as created by God: "He made them in his image: man and woman He made them." (Genesis 1:27) (see Role of women in Judaism, Christian views of women, Gender roles in Islam).
Psychology
Some studies show that males are more inclined to risky behavior than females
In one large scale study, most cognitive abilities and psychological
traits showed little or no average difference between the sexes [1]. Where sex differences exist, there is often considerable overlap between the sexes[2];
in addition, it is unclear how many of these differences hold true
across different cultures. Nevertheless, certain trends tend to be
found.
Risk taking
In many situations, men are more prone to taking risks.[3]
Personality tests
- In the big five personality traits,
women score higher in Agreeableness (tendency to be compassionate and
cooperative) and Neuroticism (tendency to feel anxiety, anger, and
depression).
- Demographics of MBTI surveys indicate that 60-75% of women prefer feeling and 55-80% of men prefer thinking.[4][5]
Aggression
-
Males are generally more aggressive
than females (Coi & Dodge 1997, Maccoby & Jacklin 1974, Buss
2005). There is evidence that males are quicker to aggression (Frey et
al 2003) and more likely than females to express their aggression
physically (Bjorkqvist et al. 1994). However, some researchers (such as
Rachel Simmons)
have suggested that females are not necessarily less aggressive, but
that they tend to show their aggression in less overt, less physical
ways (Bjorkqvist et al. 1994, Hines and Saudino 2003). For example,
females may display more verbal and relational aggression, such as
social rejection.
Systematizing and empathizing
Females score higher on self-report scales of empathy,
on samples ranging from school-age children to adults. Empathy scales
include measures of perspective taking, orientation towards another
person, empathic concern, and personal distress. However, such measures
are subjective and empathy may be more related to gender role rather than sex.[6]
Simon Baron-Cohen's EQ SQ Theory
claims that, in general, men are better at systematizing (the desire to
analyze and explore systems and rules) and that women are better at
empathizing (the ability to identify with other people’s feelings).
More males than females are diagnosed with autism and Asperger syndrome. According to Cohen, since autistic and Asperger individuals are very high in systematizing, albeit often in a manner which is hyperfocused,
and may even oversimplify more complex systems due to missing certain
details, and very low in empathizing as well, they are examples of an
"extreme male brain." [7]
Intelligence
-
Most studies show significant difference in the average IQ for men and women. Men's IQ is 2-5 % more than the average female. [1]
However, on average men perform better on tests of spatial and
mathematical ability, while women perform better on tests of verbal
ability and memory.
Also, men's IQ has greater variance, that is, there are more men than
women in the very high and very low IQ groups, with women's scores more
concentrated around the average.[1] [2] [3]
Communication
Deborah Tannen’s studies found these gender differences in communication styles:[8]
- Men tend to talk more than women in public situations, but women tend to talk more than men at home.
- Females are more inclined to face each other and make eye contact
when talking, while males are more likely to look away from each other.
- Girls and women tend to talk at length about one topic, but boys and men tend to jump from topic to topic.
- When listening, women make more noises such as “mm-hmm” and “uh-huh”, while men are more likely to listen silently.
- Women are inclined to express agreement and support, while men are more inclined to debate.
However, not all research supports these claims. One study by Erina MacGeorge
found only a 2% difference in the conversational styles of men and
women, and reported that in general both sexes communicated in similar
ways [9]. Critics, including Suzette Haden Elgin,
have suggested that Tannen's findings may apply more to women of
certain specific cultural and economic groups than to women in general.
There is no evidence to support the belief that women speak far more
words than men.[10][11][12]
Happiness
A commentary released by Pew Research Center addressed some questions about the way men and women view their lives:[13]
- Overall, women claim to be far happier than men with their lives,
and reported more often that they had made personal progress in the
last five years.
- Women show greater concern about family and home life issues, while
men express more concern about political issues. Men are happier with
their family life and more optimistic about their personal future and
that of their children.
Problems with research
Studies of psychological gender differences are controversial and
subject to error. Many small-scale studies report differences that are
not repeated in larger studies. Self-report questionnaires are subject
to bias, particularly if the subjects are told that the questionnaire
is testing for gender roles. It is also possible that commentators may
exaggerate or downplay differences for ideological reasons.
Economics
Income
-
In many countries, there is a gender income gap which favors males in the labor market.
For example, the median salary for U.S. women is 76% of that of U.S.
men; however, studies find that U.S. women earn 98% of what men do when
controlled for experience, education, and number of years on the job. Thomas Sowell, in his Knowledge and Decisions
explains that this difference is due to women not taking jobs due to
marriage pregnancy. Comparing men and women who have been continually
employed since college, women make slightly more. The income
gap in other countries ranges from 53% in Botswana to 92% in Malta.
There is a debate to what extent this is the result of gender
differences, lifestyle choices, or because of discrimination.
Employment
Nursing traditionally attracts more women than men
According to a 2004 report by the US department of labor [14]:
- 52.9% of American women are in the labor force versus 73.3% of men.
- 70.7% of women with children under 18 are in the workforce (up from
47% in 1975), compared with 94% of men with children under 18.
- Approximately 26 percent of employed women usually work part time, compared with about 11 percent of employed men.
- 5.6% of employed women and 8% of men are self-employed.
- Women in nonagricultural industries work 35.9 hours per week versus 41.6 hours for men.
- Women account for more than half of all workers in the following
industries: financial activities, education services, healthcare,
leisure and hospitality, and office and administrative support. Women
are far more likely than men to be social workers, paralegals and legal
assistants, teachers, nurses, speech pathologists, dental hygienists,
maids and housekeeping cleaners, and childcare workers.
- More men than women work in the following industries: mining,
construction, transportation and utilities, farming, computer and
mathematical occupations, engineering, and architecture. Men are far
more likely than women to be chief executives, firefighters, police and
patrol officers, electricians, dentists, and surgeons.
The Urban Institute reported in 2000 that male teens in the U.S. are more likely than female teens to work 20 or more hours per week [15].
Occupational death
The majority of occupational deaths occur among men. In one U.S.
study, 93% of deaths on the job involved men, with a death rate
approximately 11 times higher than women. The industries with the
highest death rates are mining, agriculture/forestry/fishing, and
construction, all of which tend to naturally employ more men than women
due to physical requirements [16].
Parental leave
Many countries, including Mexico, India, Germany, Brazil, and Australia require companies to grant 12-week maternity leave for working women at full pay. Paternity leave
is not available to the same extent, although in Israel for example,
parents can use this parental leave as they see fit, dividing the 12
weeks among themselves if necessary regardless of sex. Another example
is Sweden where there is equal rights to take maternity/paternity
leave. The duration is 18 months per child with 80% of full pay. Each
parent must be at home minimum 60 days to qualify for the maximum pay.
Insurance
Insurance companies often charge different rates for men and women:
Consumer behaviour
Price discrimination
can favour either men or women. For example, some night clubs offer
discounts or free entry for women, while some hairdressers offer
cheaper haircuts for men.
According to a 2000 report, women purchase or influence the purchase of 80% of all consumer goods and influence 80% of health-care decisions [17].
Education
Since the 20th century, girls have been increasingly likely to attend school and college
Worldwide, men are more likely to be literate,
with 100 men considered literate for every 88 women. In some countries
the difference is even greater; for example, in Bangladesh only 62
women are literate for every 100 men [18].
In an OECD study of 43 developed countries, 15-year-old boys were
ahead of girls in literacy skills and were more confident than girls
about getting high-income jobs [19].
As of October 2005, women made up 57% of all college students in the United States[20]. This is repeated in other countries; for example, women make up 58% of admissions in the UK [21] and 60% in Iran [22].
Suicide
-
In western countries, males are much more likely to die by suicide
than females (usually by a factor of 3–4:1); 69 out of 74 non-western
countries found an excess male mortality from suicide.
While there are more completed male suicides than female, females
are more likely to attempt suicide. One possible explanation is that
males tend to use more immediately lethal methods than females. Another
theory is that females are more likely to use self-harm as a cry for
help or attention while males are more likely to genuinely want to end
their lives.
Males between the ages of 20-24 have an average of 7 times more
suicide rate. In 2003, a study shows that males between the ages of
20-24, 202,500 males committed suicide. Compared to females between the
ages of 20-24 who are significantly less at 34,000 [4]
Crime
-
Men are much more likely to be incarcerated than women, although women are a fast-growing demographic group in prison.[23] Males are more likely than females to commit murder.[24] Men are also far more likely than women to be the victims of violent crime.[25]
Internet issues
Internet use
Men have a larger presence on the Internet
In an American study, the percentage of men using the Internet
was ahead of the percentage of women, although this difference
disappeared in the under 30s. Men log on more often, spend more time
online, and are more likely to be broadband users. Women are more likely to e-mail
friends and family about a variety of topics. Men are more likely to
use the Internet to pay bills, participate in auctions, and for
recreation such as downloading music and videos. Men and women are
equally likely to use the Internet for shopping and banking.[26]
Gender-related preferences in web site design
A study was performed at the University of Maryland in 2007
which was designed to determine gender differences in preference for
various aspects of web site design. Previous studies, in particular one
performed at the University of Glamorgan Key website research highlights gender bias,
indicated measurable differences between men and women, with each
gender tending to prefer sites designed by their own gender. Women
showed a preference for pages with more color in the background and
typeface, and more rounded shapes. Women also favored informal rather
than posed pictures. Men responded better to dark colors and a more
linear design. They also were more pleased by a three-dimensional look
and images of “self-propelling” rather than stationary objects. The
Maryland study sought to confirm these differences.
The subjects were given pairs of web sites to visit and were asked
to fill out a short questionnaire immediately afterward. The
questionnaires asked simple questions about their reaction to the
colors, graphics, site organization as well as an open-ended question
in which they were asked to describe their subjective impressions of
the sites. Web sites were selected to present significant design
dissimilarities so as to assess differences in site design preference.
One pair was specifically selected because the sites themselves
targeted at male and female users respectively.
The results generally supported earlier research. Women showed a
distinct preference for more color and graphics. In addition, while the
object scores for the male and female-targeted sites were not
significantly different, women showed a significantly higher preference
for the female-targeted site. However, it is clear from the responses
to the open-ended questions that site content was a significant factor
in determine preference for one site over another. It is therefore
suggested that in any future study real web sites not be used, but
instead neutral-content sites should be designed with variations in
style, to eliminate the bias introduced by the site content.
Marriage and sexuality
Women tend to marry at a younger age
Dating and marriage customs are dependent on culture and differ
greatly across countries and even in subcultures within the same
country. For example, many marriages in India are arranged,
whereas in the Western World most people choose their own partners. In
most societies, men are generally expected to play the more active role
in the early stages of courtship, for example in asking the woman for a date.
Age at first marriage
-
Men are older, on average, when they marry.
Sexual orientation
The demographics of sexual orientation
in any population is difficult to establish with reasonable accuracy.
However, most surveys find that a greater proportion of men than women
report that they are exclusively homosexual, whereas more women than men report being bisexual. In most societies, homosexual and bisexual women are more widely accepted than their male counterparts.
Studies have shown that heterosexual men are only aroused by images
of women. Whereas heterosexual women are aroused by images of both men
and women [5].
However, this may be the result of differences in how arousal is
measured since different methods are required for the anatomy of a man
versus that of a woman.
Numbers of unmarried people
In the USA, single men are greatly outnumbered by single women at a ratio of 100 single women to every 86 single men [27].
This very much depends on age group, with 118 single men per 100 single
women in their 20s, versus 33 single men to 100 single women over 65.[28]
The numbers are different in other countries. For example, China has
many more young men than young women, and this disparity is expected to
increase.[29] In regions with recent conflict such as Chechnya, women may greatly outnumber men.[30]
Online dating
There are still more men than women in online dating
websites. According to a November 2003 study by Jupiter Research, men
are four times more likely than women to subscribe to an online dating
site and twice as likely to browse, post, or respond to a profile. [31]
Choosing a partner
In a cross-cultural study by David Buss,
men and women were asked to rank certain traits in order of importance
in a long-term partner. Both men and women ranked "kindness" and
"intelligence" as the two most important factors. Men valued beauty and
youth more highly than women, while women valued financial and social
status more highly than men.[32]
Orgasm
- Men's orgasm
is essential for reproduction whereas female orgasm is not. The female
orgasm was believed to have no obvious function other than to be
pleasurable although recent evidence suggests that it may have evolved
as a discriminatory advantage in regards to mate selection. Psychology Today, The Orgasm Wars
- Typical male orgasmic contractions lasts no more than a couple of
seconds, while in women, such contractions lasting up to a minute are
known.
- According to Kinsey,
for about 75% of all males, orgasm is possible to be attained within
the first two minutes after initiation of sexual intercourse. For women
the average time to reach orgasm is between 10 and 20 minutes. The
swiftness of the male system virtually guarantees climactic orgasms for
males but is usually too quick to give the female a penetration-induced
orgasm. However, the average time to female orgasm via masturbation is
significantly less at four minutes (those two citations contain nothing on the average orgasm masturbation time)[33] [34].
- Male circumcision (removal of the foreskin) does not prevent the ability to orgasm, but female genital cutting
usually does. However, the two procedures are not directly comparable;
in particular, the phrase "female genital cutting" is used to refer to
a wide variety of different practices, from minor ritual cuts to the labia (which are much less likely to impede orgasm) to complete excision of the clitoris.
Clothing
Clothing norms depend on culture
In most cultures, different sorts of clothing are considered appropriate for men and women.
- In Western societies, skirts and dresses and high-heeled shoes are usually seen as women's clothing, while neckties are generally worn by men. Trousers
were once seen as exclusively male clothing, but are nowadays worn by
both sexes. Male clothes are often more practical (that is, they can
function well under a wide variety of situations), but a wider range of
clothing styles is available for females. Males are typically allowed
to bare their chests
in a greater variety of public places. It is generally acceptable, to
some degree, for a woman to wear traditionally male clothing, but not
the other way around.
- In some cultures, sumptuary laws regulate what men and women are required to wear.
- Islam requires both sexes to wear hijab,
or modest clothing. What qualifies as "modest" varies in different
Muslim societies; however, women are usually required to cover more of
their bodies than men are. Articles of clothing worn by Muslim women
for purposes of modesty range from the headscarf to the burqa.
- Scottish men may choose to wear kilts
on ceremonial occasions. Kilts were previously worn as normal clothing
by men. Men not of Scottish descent are increasingly wearing kilts
today.
- Compared to men's clothing, women's clothing tends to address being
looked at. In the modern West, women are more likely to wear makeup,
jewelry, and colorful clothing, while in very traditional cultures
women are protected from men's gazes by modest dress.
Miscellaneous
Males tend to play in more sports
- Men have more responsibilities and presence in many religions or religious organizations. For example, the Roman Catholic church forbids women to become priests.
- Some societies place restrictions on women during their menstrual cycle.
- Men and boys participate in more sports.
- Women take longer to use the bathroom (see potty parity).
- Typically, women spend more time than men doing childcare and household chores (see homemaker).
- In general, women are more involved than men with children.
- Generally, males take more of an interest in video games than do females, although certain genres have a large number of female players as well.
See also
Notes
- ^ Gender-related features of skin Procter & Gamble Haircare Research Centre 1997
- ^ Bren, Linda (2005) Does Sex Make a Difference? FDA Consumer magazine, July-August 2005 Issue
- ^ Marano, Hara Estroff (2003) The New Sex Scorecard Psychology Today Magazine, Publication Date: Jul/Aug 2003, Last Reviewed: 9 Sep 2005
- ^ Harasty J, Double KL, Halliday GM, Kril JJ, McRitchie DA. (1997) Language-associated cortical regions are proportionally larger in the female brain Archives of Neurology 1997 Feb;54(2):171-6.
- ^ Frederikse ME, Lu A, Aylward E, Barta P, Pearlson G. (1999) Sex differences in the inferior parietal lobe Cerebral Cortex. 1999 Dec;9(8):896-901
- ^ WHO Countries A list that provides links to statistics on various countries, including life expectancy.
- ^ Lifestyle 'hits life length gap' BBC September 16, 2005
- ^ A Country of Widows Viktor Perevedentsev, New Times, May 2006
- ^ Gender, women, and health Reports from WHO 2002-2005
- ^ Hyde, J. S. (2005) The Gender Similarities HypothesisPDF (129 KiB) American Psychologist, Vol. 60, No. 6, pp. 581-592. See also: Men and Women: No Big Difference on the APA-sponsored website, www.psychologymatters.org.
- ^ Young, Cathy (1999) Sex and Sensibility Reason, March 1999
- ^ Larkin, Judith E. (2003) Gender and risk in public performance Sex Roles: A Journal of Research
- ^ Estimated Frequencies of the Types in the United States Population
- ^ Gender differences in the distribution of types in AustraliaPDF (52.1 KiB)
- ^ Rachel Karniol, Rivi Gabay, Yael Ochion, Yael Harari (1998) Is gender or gender-role orientation a better predictor of empathy in adolescence? Sex Roles: A Journal of Research, July, 1998
- ^ Baron-Cohen, Simon (2003) 'They just can't help it' The Guardian April 17, 2003
- ^ Tannen, Deborah (1990) Sex, Lies and Conversation; Why Is It So Hard for Men and Women to Talk to Each Other? The Washington Post, June 24, 1990
- ^ MacGeorge, Erina (2004) Purdue study shows men, women share same planet Purdue News, February 17, 2004
- ^ Liberman, Mark (2006) Sex-Linked Lexical Budgets Language Log, August 06, 2006
- ^
Hyde, Janet Shibley and Linn, Marcia C. (1988) "Gender Differences in
Verbal Ability: A Meta-Analysis", Psychological Bulletin, 104:1 53-69
- ^
James, Deborah and Drakich, Janice (1993) "Understanding Gender
Differences in Amount of Talk: A Critical Review of Research", in D.
Tannen, (ed.) Gender and Conversational Interaction. Oxford University Press: New York and Oxford.
- ^ Global Gender Gaps: Women Like Their Lives Better Pew Research Center October 29, 2003
- ^ Women in the Labor Force: A DatabookPDF (630 KiB) US Dept of Labor 2005
- ^ Are Teens in Low-Income and Welfare Families Working Too Much? Robert I. Lerman, Urban Institute, November 01, 2000
- ^ Fatal Occupational Injuries - United States, 1980-1997 MMWR Weekly, April 27, 2001
- ^ Popcorn, Faith and Hyperion, Lys Marigold (2000) EVEolution – The Eight Truths of Marketing to Women New York. (ISBN 0-7868-6523-7)
- ^ Illiteracy 'hinders world's poor' BBC November 09, 2005
- ^ 'Girls top of the class worldwide' BBC September 16, 2003
- ^ College gender gap USA Today October 19, 2005
- ^ 'Where have all the young men gone? ' The Guardian May 18, 2004
- ^ 'In Iran, More Women Leaving Nest for University' The New York Times July 22, 2000
- ^ Prevalence of Imprisonment in the U.S. Population, 1974-2001 U.S. Department of Justice Special Report, August 2003, NCJ 197976.
- ^ Most victims and perpetrators in homicides are male U.S. Department of Justice · Office of Justice Programs Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2004
- ^ Sex Differences in Violent Victimization U.S. Department of Justice Special Report September 1997, NCJ-164508.
- ^ How men and women use the Internet Pew Research Center December 28, 2005
- ^ 'Men hold the edge on gender gap odds' Oakland Tribune October 21, 2003
- ^ Facts for features: Valentine’s Day U.S. Census Bureau Report February 7, 2006
- ^ '40m Bachelors And No Women' The Guardian March 09, 2004
- ^ 'Polygamy Proposal for Chechen Men' BBC January 13, 2006
- ^ Scott, Kenneth (2005) 'Why Online Dating is So Tough For Men' solveyourproblem.com February 3, 2005
- ^ Buss, D. M. (2003). The evolution of desire: Strategies of human mating. New York: Basic Books. (ISBN 0-465-02143-3)
- ^ Sexual Averages 1997-2003 Holodyne, Inc.
- ^ The story of Ohh! The Guardian 28 April 2004
- ^ a b Larry
V. Hedges; Amy Nowell (1995). "Sex Differences in Mental Test Scores,
Variability, and Numbers of High-Scoring Individuals". Science 269: 41-45.
- ^ IJ
Deary, G Thorpe, V Wilson, JM Starr, LJ Whalley (2003). "Population sex
differences in IQ at age 11: the Scottish mental survey 1932". Intelligence 31: 533–542.
- ^ Ian J. Deary,
Paul Irwing, Geoff Der and Timothy C. Bates. Brother–sister differences
in the g factor in intelligence: Analysis of full, opposite-sex
siblings from the NLSY1979. Intelligence, In Press. doi:10.1016/j.intell.2006.09.003
- ^ http://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/.../youthsuicide.htm
- ^ Pas de Deux of Sexuality Is Written in the Genes
Further reading
This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from Wikipedia Encyclopedia article "Gender Differences"
|