Thomas Parnell: The Pitch Drop Experiment

Thomas Parnell
The Pitch Drop Experiment
Hands On Activity: My Putty Drop Experiment


Home Projects Experiments Warning!

The Pitch Drop Experiment

Thomas Parnell's pitch drop experiment from 1927
John Mainstone - CC 3.0 GNU 1.2

The purpose of the Pitch Drop Experiment is to demonstrate that there are materials that even if they look solid at room temperature, like pitch that could be smashed by a hammer blow, they are as a matter of fact high viscosity fluids.

The meaning is that pitch, for example, can flow, at room temperature, very slowly and form a single drop after a few years.

To test this assumption there is a need for a long term experiment.

The experiment was initiated in 1927 by Thomas Parnell (1881 – 1948) who was the first Professor of Physics at the University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia. Parnell poured melted pitch into a blocked glass funnel and allowed it to settle down for three years. In 1930 the neck of the funnel was unblocked and the pitch started flowing. Drops formed slowly and fell approximately every ten years a drop. Till now fell eight drops and the ninth is expected in 2012 or 2013.

In 2005, John Mainstone, experiment's current custodian, and Thomas Parnell (died in 1948) were awarded the Ig Nobel Prize in Physics for the pitch drop experiment.

To date, no one has ever witnessed a drop fall. The experiment is in permanent view of a webcam although technical problems prevented the most recent drop (the 8th) from being recorded.

The experiment is on public display in the Parnell Building, School of Physics, St Lucia campus, University of Queensland, Australia.

Experiment Timeline:
1927 - Experiment set up
1930 - The funnel stem was unblocked
1938 - 1st drop fell - 8 years interval
1947 - 2nd drop fell - 8 years interval
1954 - 3rd drop fell - 7 years interval
1962 - 4th drop fell - 8 years interval
1970 - 5th drop fell - 8 years interval
1979 - 6th drop fell - 9 years interval
1988 - 7th drop fell - 9 years interval
2000 - 8th drop fell - 12 years interval
Source: Wikipedia

See also:
http://www.smp.uq.edu.au...
http://www.physics.uq.edu.au...

In 1927, the St Andrew's University in Scotland also has started a pitch drop experiment of its own. While the Parnell experiment has produced a series of drops, the pitch at St Andrew's flows out in a continuous dribble maybe because of the difference between the pitch samples. (http://www.uq.edu.au...)

In 1887, Lord Kelvin started his pitch glacier experiment at Glasgow University which is still going. In this experiment a pitch bulk flows very slowly unnoticed down a slide. Kelvin's experiment demonstrated that small consistent forces, such as gravity, are able to produce big changes in the shape of a substance over long periods of time. However, Kelvin's objective was not to demonstrate properties of matter but to illustrate properties of ether (out of scope for this page). (http://thatsmaths.com)

Point of Controversy: such experiments and others led some to the view that solids are as a matter of fact liquids with a very high viscosity.

My Putty Drop Experiment

My Putty Drop Experiment from May 2012

For school demonstrations or science fair projects is not practical to wait a decade or so to witness a pitch drop. So we suggest trying other materials that have lower viscosity that will provide results in weeks or months but not years.

For this experiment we chose sta-put putty (plumbers putty / window putty) that even if it doesn't harden completely it still has a very high viscosity (108 times of that of water but substantial lower than pitch's 2.3×1011) and hopefully it will produce drops in a reasonable time and by that it will demonstrate Parnell's point that sometimes solids (look like) are high viscosity fluids that can flow, but very slowly, and even can form drops like liquids.

Other possible material is plasteline.

The funnel was sealed and filled with putty to the brim. The malleable putty was compressed into the funnel, as much as possible, using hands. Now we are going to leave it settle down to eliminate air bubbles if such were created in the compression process. When the level of putty goes down a few millimeters it's time to cut the stem, if not we are going to wait one year before we do it.

The experiment was set up in 20 May 2012 in Dimona, Israel where the temperature fluctuates most of the time between 10°C (January) to 35 °C (August).

We are going to use the data collected from this experiment (if successful) to calculate the viscosity of putty and compare the obtained value to more official data.

We are going to keep our readers updated on new developments on the following experiment log ASAP.

The Putty Drop Experiment Log

20 May 2012 - The experiment starts (see above).

22 May 2013 - The neck of the funnel is cut.

22 May 2018 - No drop forms

Links of Interest

University of Queensland page on the Pitch Drop experiment with live webcam
Pitch Drop Experiment - Wikipedia
Is this the most boring experiment ever? Scientists watch drops of pitch form - Mail Online
A Test of Patience



Scientists & Inventors
Ampère André-Marie
Archimedes
Baird John
Bell Alexander
Carver George
Cavendish Henry
Darwin Charles
DNA
Eastman George
Edison Thomas 1
Edison Thomas 2
Einstein Albert
Electric Motor
Eratosthenes
Faraday Michael
Fitzroy Robert
Foucault Léon
Franklin Benjamin
Fuel Cell
Galileo Galilei 1
Galileo Galilei 2
Gutenberg Johannes
Hertz Heinrich
Joule, James Prescott
Leonardo da Vinci
Leeuwenhoek Antonie
Marconi Guglielmo
Mendel Gregor
Michelson-Morley
Miller-Urey Experiment
Millikan Robert
Morse Samuel
Newton Isaac
Ohm Georg
Oxygen
Pavlov & Skinner
Photosynthesis
Pitch Drop Experiment
Radio Inventions
Spectrum of Light
Tesla Nikola
Torricelli Evangelista
Transistor
Tycho Brahe
Volta Alessandro
Whitney Eli
Wright Brothers
Young Thomas
Zuse Konrad
Ampère André-Marie

Home Fair Projects Experiments
Scientists & Inventors Science Jokes Warning!



Follow Us On:
       

Privacy Policy - Site Map - About Us - Letters to the Editor

Comments and inquiries:
webmaster@julianTrubin.com


Last updated: February 2018
Copyright 2003-2018 Julian Rubin